Saint Paul logo
File #: Ord 18-49    Version:
Type: Ordinance Status: Passed
In control: City Council
Final action: 10/24/2018
Title: Amending the zoning map as recommended in the West Marshall Avenue Zoning Study.
Sponsors: Samantha Henningson, Dai Thao
Attachments: 1. Planning Commission Resolution 08-10-18, 2. Planning Commission Action Minutes 08-10-18, 3. Planning Commission Minutes for 08-10-18, 4. West Marshall Avenue Zoning Study Memo 07-25-18, 5. Planning Commission Minutes from Public Hearing 06-29-18, 6. Written Comments Submitted to Planning Commission 06-29-18, 7. Planning Commission Resolution to Amend the Study Area 05-18-18, 8. Planning Commission Minutes 05-18-18, 9. Union Park District Council Letter, 10. West Marshall PH Staff Presentation, 11. Dean Nelson email and attachments, 12. Comment rec'd by Council re West Marshall Zoning Study, 13. Comment rec'd by Council re West Marshall Rezoning 2, 14. Study Segments Zoning Maps 10.03.pdf, 15. Nelson email and attachments 10-1-18, 16. Allchin email and attachments 10-2-18, 17. Online comment re West Marshall rezoning, 18. Public Hearing Slides for 10.17.pdf, 19. Comment OPPOSING Amended West Marshall Rezoning, 20. Comment2 OPPOSING Amended West Marshall Rezoning, 21. Comment SUPPORTING Amended West Marshall Rezoning
Related files: RES 17-1713
Date Ver.Action ByActionResultAction DetailsMeeting DetailsVideo
10/31/20182 Mayor's Office Signed  Action details Meeting details Not available
10/24/20182 City Council Adopted As AmendedPass Action details Meeting details Video Video
10/17/20182 City Council Amended and Laid Over for Final AdoptionPass Action details Meeting details Video Video
10/3/20181 City Council Laid Over to Public HearingPass Action details Meeting details Video Video
9/26/20181 City Council Public Hearing Closed; Laid Over to Fourth Reading/Final AdoptionPass Action details Meeting details Video Video
9/19/20181 City Council Continue Public HearingPass Action details Meeting details Video Video
9/12/20181 City Council Laid Over to Third Reading/Public Hearing  Action details Meeting details Video Video
9/5/20181 City Council Laid Over to Second Reading  Action details Meeting details Video Video

Title

Amending the zoning map as recommended in the West Marshall Avenue Zoning Study.

 

Body

STATEMENT OF FINDINGS BY THE CITY COUNCIL

 

WHEREAS, pursuant to Sec. 61.801(b) of the Saint Paul Zoning Code, the Saint Paul City Council, with Resolution 17-1713, on October 18, 2017, initiated the West Marshall Avenue

Zoning Study for property along Marshall Avenue from the Mississippi River to Hamline Avenue; and

 

WHEREAS, the study area includes all parcels with frontage along Marshall Avenue and those parcels added to the study area by the Planning Commission in its Resolutions 18-35 and 18-62 for a total study area in excess of 40 acres; and

 

WHEREAS, given the number of real estate descriptions that could be affected by amendment or alteration of the zoning ordinance, the Planning Commission determined that obtaining written consent from property owners would be impractical; and

 

WHEREAS, on August 10, 2018, following a duly noticed public hearing that was held on June 29, 2018, the Planning Commission recommended the rezoning of a number of parcels in the study area in accordance with and related to the West Marshall Avenue Zoning Study and to the overall needs of the community as documented in the study dated July 25, 2018; and

 

WHEREAS, on September 19, 2018, following a duly noticed public hearing before the City Council where all interested parties were afforded the opportunity to be heard, the Council considered all the facts, recommendations, and testimony regarding the proposed zoning amendments, pursuant to the authority granted by and in accordance with the procedures set forth in Minnesota Statutes § 462.357

 

THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN

 

SECTION 1

 

That the Zoning Map of Saint Paul, incorporated in Legislative Code § 60.303, is hereby amended as follows:

 

Parcel ID Number  Address

Existing

Rezone to

 

042823220001

2032 Marshall Ave

B2

T2

042823220004

2044 Marshall Ave

B2

T3

042823220005

2054 Marshall Ave

B2

T3

052823120009

2190 Marshall Ave

B2

T3

342923330135

1560 Iglehart Ave

B3

IT

342923330136

0 Marshall Ave

B3

IT

332923330114

2027 Marshall Ave

B3

T2

332923330116

2045 Marshall Ave

B3

T2

342923330099

1535 Marshall Ave

I1

T3

342923330100

1525 Marshall Ave

I1

T3

342923330101

1519 Marshall Ave

I1

T3

342923330102

1515 Marshall Ave

I1

T3

342923330106

1479 Marshall Ave

I1

T3

342923330107

1471 Marshall Ave

I1

T3

342923330142

1481 Marshall Ave

I1

T3

342923330151

1509 Marshall Ave

I1

T3

052823120001

2236 Marshall Ave

OS

T2

322923440115

2173 Marshall Ave

R3

RM1

322923440116

2171 Marshall Ave

R3

RM1

322923440117

2163 Marshall Ave

R3

RM1

322923440118

2159 Marshall Ave

R3

RM1

322923440119

2155 Marshall Ave

R3

RM1

322923440120

2149 Marshall Ave

R3

RM1

322923440121

2143 Marshall Ave

R3

RM1

322923440122

2137 Marshall Ave

R3

RM1

322923440123

2127 Marshall Ave

R3

RM1

322923440124

2115 Marshall Ave

R3

RM1

322923440125

2111 Marshall Ave

R3

RM1

322923440126

2103 Marshall Ave

R3

RM1

322923440127

2097 Marshall Ave

R3

RM1

322923440128

2093 Marshall Ave

R3

RM1

322923440129

2089 Marshall Ave

R3

RM1

322923440130

2083 Marshall Ave

R3

T2

322923440131

2077 Marshall Ave

R3

T2

322923440132

2073 Marshall Ave

R3

T2

322923440133

2069 Marshall Ave

R3

T2

322923440134

2063 Marshall Ave

R3

T3

052823110007

2090 Marshall Ave

R4

RM1

052823110008

2094 Marshall Ave

R4

RM1

052823110009

2098 Marshall Ave

R4

RM1

052823110010

2100 Marshall Ave

R4

RM1

052823110011

2106 Marshall Ave

R4

RM1

052823110012

2110 Marshall Ave

R4

RM1

052823110013

2114 Marshall Ave

R4

RM1

052823110014

2118 Marshall Ave

R4

RM1

052823110066

2128 Marshall Ave

R4

RM1

052823110067

2134 Marshall Ave

R4

RM1

052823110068

2138 Marshall Ave

R4

RM1

052823110069

2142 Marshall Ave

R4

RM1

052823110070

2146 Marshall Ave

R4

RM1

052823110071

2150 Marshall Ave

R4

RM1

052823110072

2156 Marshall Ave

R4

RM1

052823110073

2158 Marshall Ave

R4

RM1

052823110074

2162 Marshall Ave

R4

RM1

052823110075

2166 Marshall Ave

R4

RM1

052823110065

2122 Marshall Ave

R4

RM1

042823120101

1756 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823120102

1764 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823120103

1768 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823120104

1772 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823120105

1778 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823120106

1782 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823120107

1786 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823120108

1790 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823120109

1794 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823120110

1798 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823120111

1802 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823210001

1904 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823210002

1910 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823210003

1920 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823210004

1926 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823210010

1852 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823210011

1856 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823210012

1864 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823210013

1866 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823210014

1872 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823210015

1880 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823210016

1894 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823210017

1898 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823210018

224 Howell St N

RM2

RM1

042823210030

1836 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823210031

1840 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823210032

1846 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823220012

1984 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823220013

1990 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823220014

1996 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823220015

2000 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823220016

2006 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823220017

2010 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823220018

2016 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823220019

226 Wilder St N

RM2

RM1

042823220025

1964 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823220026

1968 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823220027

1974 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823220028

1980 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923330014

1954 Iglehart Ave

RM2

RM1

332923330023

1969 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923330024

1963 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923330058

2017 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923330059

2013 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923330060

2005 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923330061

1999 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923330062

1995 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923330063

1991 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923330064

1985 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923340095

1899 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923340096

1893 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923340097

1885 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923340098

1879 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923340099

1873 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923340100

1869 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923340101

1863 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923340102

1853 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923340123

1940 Iglehart Ave

RM2

RM1

332923340125

1925 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923340126

1921 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923340127

1915 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923340128

1907 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923430088

1809 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923430089

1805 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923430090

1801 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923430091

1797 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923430092

1793 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923430093

1785 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923430094

1783 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923430095

1777 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923430096

1775 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923430097

1769 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923430098

1765 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

332923430099

1759 Marshall Ave

RM2

RM1

042823120112

1806 Marshall Ave

RM2

T1

042823120113

1810 Marshall Ave

RM2

T1

042823120114

1814 Marshall Ave

RM2

T1

042823120115

224 Fairview Ave N

RM2

T1

042823210005

1940 Marshall Ave

RM2

T1

042823210029

1824 Marshall Ave

RM2

T1

042823220024

1954 Marshall Ave

RM2

T1

052823110001

2062 Marshall Ave

RM2

T1

052823110002

2070 Marshall Ave

RM2

T1

052823110003

2074 Marshall Ave

RM2

T1

052823110004

2078 Marshall Ave

RM2

T1

052823110005

2082 Marshall Ave

RM2

T1

052823110006

2086 Marshall Ave

RM2

T1

332923330025

1955 Marshall Ave

RM2

T1

332923340032

1849 Marshall Ave

RM2

T1

332923340124

1939 Marshall Ave

RM2

T1

332923340131

1831 Marshall Ave

RM2

T1

332923430113

 

RM2

T1

052823120002

2226 Marshall Ave

RM2

T2

052823120003

2222 Marshall Ave

RM2

T2

052823120004

2214 Marshall Ave

RM2

T2

052823120067

235 Exeter Pl

RM2

T2

052823120068

234 Montrose Pl

RM2

T2

052823120118

2294 Marshall Ave

RM2

T2

052823210001

234 Mississippi River Blvd N

RM2

T2

052823210027

2338 Marshall Ave

RM2

T2

332923440066

1627 Marshall Ave

RM2

T2

332923440067

1621 Marshall Ave

RM2

T2

332923440068

1617 Marshall Ave

RM2

T2

332923440069

0 Iglehart Ave

RM2

T2

332923440070

1615 Marshall Ave

RM2

T2

332923440071

1609 Marshall Ave

RM2

T2

332923440072

1605 Marshall Ave

RM2

T2

332923440116

266 Fry St

RM2

T2

052823120007

2202 Marshall Ave

RM2

T3

052823120008

2194 Marshall Ave

RM2

T3

052823120140

2210 Marshall Ave

RM2

T3

332923440073

0 Marshall Ave

RM2

T3

042823110069

1664 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823110070

1660 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823110071

1656 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823110072

1652 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823110073

1648 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823110074

1642 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823110075

1638 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823110076

1634 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823110077

1630 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823110137

1698 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823110138

1690 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823110139

1688 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823110140

1684 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823110141

1680 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823110142

1676 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823110143

1670 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823120001

1724 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823120002

1720 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823120003

1716 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823120004

1712 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823120005

1708 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823120006

1700 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823120051

1730 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823120052

1736 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823120053

1740 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823120054

1744 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823120055

1748 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

042823120056

1754 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923430056

1727 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923430057

1723 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923430058

1717 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923430059

1711 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923430060

1703 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923430068

1747 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923430069

1743 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923430070

1739 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923430071

1735 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923430072

1731 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923430106

1753 Marshall Ave  1

RT1

RM1

332923430107

1753 Marshall Ave  2

RT1

RM1

332923430108

1753 Marshall Ave  3

RT1

RM1

332923430109

1753 Marshall Ave  4

RT1

RM1

332923430110

1753 Marshall Ave  5

RT1

RM1

332923430111

254 Wheeler St N 1

RT1

RM1

332923430112

254 Wheeler St N 2

RT1

RM1

332923440086

1665 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923440087

1661 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923440088

1657 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923440089

1651 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923440090

1649 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923440091

1641 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923440092

1639 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923440093

1635 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923440094

1631 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923440101

1699 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923440102

1691 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923440103

1689 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923440104

1683 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923440105

1677 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

332923440106

1671 Marshall Ave

RT1

RM1

032823210001

235 Hamline Ave N

RT1

T1

032823210009

199 Hamline Ave N

RT1

T1

032823210010

0 Hamline Ave N

RT1

T1

032823210011

0 Hamline Ave N

RT1

T1

032823210012

187 Hamline Ave N

RT1

T1

032823210013

1347 Selby Ave

RT1

T1

032823210016

0 Selby Ave

RT1

T1

032823210017

0 Selby Ave

RT1

T1

032823210018

1397 Selby Ave

RT1

T1

032823210081

0 Selby Ave

RT1

T1

042823220002

225 Wilder St N

RT1

T2

042823110008

1619 Dayton Ave

T1

T2

042823220003

2034 Marshall Ave

T2

T3

052823120010

2180 Marshall Ave

T2

T3

 

SECTION 2

This ordinance shall become effective thirty (30) days after its passage, approval, and publication.

 

Date NameDistrictOpinionCommentAction
10/11/2018 8:58 PMBen Ashley-Wurtmann For While I am sorry to see any downzoning aong Marshall, I do applaud CM Nelson’s amendment. Preserving opportunities for transit oriented growth along the vital 21/53 bus route is a must do thing for St Paul. We recently received news that the world will see deadly and irreversible climate change in a decade. The least we can do for those who would like to live longer than 12 more years is to better promote places where it’s easy to be car free to live, work and play. +5 -4 2