Saint Paul logo
File #: ABZA 25-2    Version: 1
Type: Appeal-BZA Status: Archived
In control: City Council
Final action: 2/19/2025
Title: Considering the appeal of Sean Ryan - Ryan Companies, US Inc. to a decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals denying two variance requests to construct a commercial building on the property at 0 Cretin Avenue South (Highland Bridge Block 2C).
Sponsors: Saura Jost
Code sections: Sec. 66.931 - Ford district dimensional standards table.
Attachments: 1. Appeal Application - Application and Narrative, 2. Appeal Application - Attachment A - HB Block 2C Variance Application, 3. Appeal Application - Attachment B - HB Block 2C Variance Narrative, 4. Appeal Application - Attachment C - HB Block 2C Variance Exhibits, 5. Appeal Application - Attachment D - HB Block 2C Variance Supplement, 6. Appeal Application - Attachment E - HB Block 2C 12.9.2024 BZA Meeting PowerPoint, 7. Appeal Application - Attachment F - HDC Resolution for Highland Bridge Lot 2C, 8. Appeal Application - Attachment G - BZA Staff Report File # 24-096392, 9. Appeal Application - Attachment H - BZA Agenda Results, December 9, 2024, 10. Appeal Application - Attachment I - BZA Agenda Results, January 6, 2025, 11. Appeal Application - C.91 - 0 Cretin Ave S HB Block 2C Extension Letter 1.3.2025, 12. Zoning Variance Application, 13. Staff Report, 14. Board of Zoning Appeals Resolution, 15. Comment - HDC Resolution for Block 2C, 16. Applicant Presentation to BZA 12.9.2024, 17. Application Supplement from Applicant Received January 3rd 2025, 18. Board of Zoning Appeals Public Hearing Notice Mailing Map & List, 19. Board of Zoning Appeals Public Hearing Notice, 20. ยง 15.99 Extension Letter for 0 Cretin Avenue South, 21. City Council Public Hearing Notice Mailing Map & List, 22. City Council Public Hearing Notice, 23. BZA General and Hearing Minutes_12092024, 24. BZA General and Hearing Minutes_01062025, 25. BZA General and Hearing Minutes_01212025, 26. Kathryn Iverson Public Comment, 27. 1.27 public comment, 28. 2.4 public comment, 29. 2.5 public comments, 30. 2.6 public comments, 31. 2.7 public comments, 32. 2.10 public comments, 33. 2.11 public comments, 34. 2.12 public comments, 35. 2.18 public comments, 36. 0 Cretin Ave S Staff Presentation, 37. Ryan Companies council slides, 38. Appellant document 1 - submitted during council public hearing, 39. Appellant document 2 - submitted during council public hearing

Title

Considering the appeal of Sean Ryan - Ryan Companies, US Inc. to a decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals denying two variance requests to construct a commercial building on the property at 0 Cretin Avenue South (Highland Bridge Block 2C).

Body

 

Zoning File: #25-007075 (Appeal of Zoning File #24-096392)

 

File Name: 0 Cretin Avenue South (Highland Bridge Block 2C) - Sean Ryan, Ryan Companies US, Inc.

 

Appellant: Sean Ryan, Ryan Companies US, Inc.

 

Applicant: Sean Ryan, Ryan Companies US, Inc.

 

Address: 0 Cretin Avenue South (Highland Bridge Block 2C)

 

Purpose: An appeal of a decision by the Board of Zoning Appeals denying two variance requests to construct a commercial building. The zoning code requires a minimum floor area ratio of 2.0 and a minimum building height of 40'; a floor area ratio of 0.3 and a building height of 18' is proposed. A public hearing was held on December 9, 2024.

 

Staff Recommendation: Approval

 

District Council Recommendation: The Highland District Council's Community Development Committee submitted a resolution supporting the variance requests.

 

Board of Zoning Appeals Decision: The Board of Zoning Appeals denied the requests via a 4-2 vote based upon findings 2, 3 and 4.

 

Support: 0 people spoke, 0 letters received

 

Opposition: 1 person spoke, 0 letters received

 

Required Background Information

 

Does this issue fall within the 60 day rule?  Yes

 

If yes, when does the 60 days expire? January 16, 2025

 

Has an extension been granted?  Yes

 

If so, to what date?  March 17, 2025

 

Key Staff Contact

David Eide (651-266-9088, david.eide@stpaul.gov)

Date NameDistrictOpinionCommentAction
No records to display.