Saint Paul logo
Share to Facebook Share to Twitter Bookmark and Share
File #: AHPC 21-2    Version: 1
Type: Appeal-HPC Status: Archived
In control: City Council
Final action: 1/27/2021
Title: Public hearing to consider the appeal of Carlos Perez, Sketches LLC on behalf of Sullivan Property Investments II, LLC to the Heritage Preservation Commission decision of 540 Portland Avenue in the Historic Hill Heritage Preservation District
Sponsors: Dai Thao
Attachments: 1. HPC Agenda, 2. 540 Portland HPC Packet, 3. Portland Views, 4. Email Chain with George Gause - HP Staff, 5. Gar Hargens email to staff 9-22-20, 6. BZA emails that HP staff were CCd on, 7. Gar Hargens email to staff 9-30-20, 8. Appeal submitted by Gar Hargens and Missy Thompson, 9. Additional Public Comment, 10. Adopted HPC Resolution, 11. Adopted HPC Minutes, 12. Letter of Appeal submitted by Carlos Perez, 13. Opposition to Sullivan Appeal, 14. Jason Patalonis Opposition Email, 15. Marcucci & Schroder Opposition Email, 16. AHPC 21-2 - Dan Chouinard and John Sularz email 1-26-21, 17. AHPC 21-2 - Eric Galatz letter 1-14-21, 18. AHPC 21-2 - SARPA letter 1-15-21, 19. AHPC 21-2 - Wendy Surprise letter 1-19-21, 20. AHPC 21-2 - Missy Staples Thompson email 1-22-21, 21. W6 comment_PeterCarlsen_540Portland_20Jan2021, 22. HPC Denial Support - received by W1, 23. HPC Opposition_Ward 2, 24. From 552 Portland_To CM Noecker, 25. Chouinard & Sularz Opposition Email, 26. Cathy Maes Letter_1.26, 27. 540 Portland Timeline, 28. W6 comments_540Portland Ave_27Jan2021

Title

Public hearing to consider the appeal of Carlos Perez, Sketches LLC on behalf of Sullivan Property Investments II, LLC to the Heritage Preservation Commission decision of 540 Portland Avenue in the Historic Hill Heritage Preservation District

Body

File Name: 540 Portland Avenue HPC Appeal

Address: 540 Portland Avenue

Purpose: Appeal of a Heritage Preservation Commission decision denying the construction of a three-unit residential structure at 540 Portland Avenue, and recommending that the applicant communicate with the neighborhood on any revision of the project.

Support: 0 people spoke, 14 letters were received

Opposition: 5 people spoke, 6 letters were received

Heritage Preservation Commission Decision: Denied, Vote: 5-2 (motion: Wagner, second: MacDonald)

Staff Assigned: Allison Suhan Eggers 651-266-6643

Attachments:

1.                     HPC Agenda

2.                     540 Portland HPC Packet which includes HP Staff Report, Application, Letters of Testimony

3.                     Portland Views

4.                     Email Chain with George Gause - HP staff

5.                     Gar Hargens email to staff 9-22-20

6.                     BZA emails that HP staff were CC’d on

7.                     Gar Hargens email to staff 9-30-20

8.                     Appeal submitted by Gar Hargens and Missy Thompson

9.                     Additional Public Comment

10.                     Adopted HPC Resolution

11.                      Adopted HPC Minutes

12.                     Letter of Appeal submitted by Carlos Perez

13.                     Opposition to Sullivan Appeal

 

Date NameDistrictOpinionCommentAction
No records to display.