Saint Paul logo
File #: RLH RSA 24-4    Version:
Type: Resolution LH Rent Stabilization Appeal Status: Passed
In control: City Council
Final action: 8/14/2024
Title: Appeal of Sumeya Mohamed to a Rent Stabilization Determination at 200 WINTHROP STREET SOUTH, APT. 313. (Amended to grant the appeal)
Sponsors: Cheniqua Johnson
Ward: Ward - 7
Attachments: 1. 200 Winthop St S Apt 313 -LHO Recommendation Letter 7-19-24, 2. 200 Winthrop St S.Appeal Ap.7-13-23, 3. 200 Winthrop Minutes 8-10-23, 4. 200 Winthrop St S.DSI Staff Determination Ltr.5-24-23, 5. 200 Winthrop St. S.Notice of Appeal & Leg Hrg Date.8-3-23, 6. 200 Winthrop St S.HJC Memo re Mohamed Appeal 7-7-23, 7. 200 Winthrop St S.Mohamed Declaration.7-7-23, 8. 200 Winthrop St S.HJC-Hanson Declaration.7-7-23, 9. 200 Winthrop St S.HJC Exhibits and Court Doc 62-CV-23-2694, 10. 200 Winthrop St S.HJC Supplemental Appeal Submission Ltr.8-9-23, 11. 200 Winthrop St S.HJC Supplemental Ltr Attached Exhibits.8-9-23, 12. 200 Winthrop St S. Mohamed Tenancy Supplement.8-17-23, 13. 200 Winthrop St S.Rent Incr Request for Staff Determination - Staff Summary Made 6-12-23, 14. 200 Winthrop St S.MNOI w Cap Impr Calcs.5-16-23, 15. 200 Winthrop St S.Rent Increase Table by Unit.5-24-23, 16. 200 Winthrop St S.Sass Email re MNOI Cap Impr Wksht.7-25-23, 17. 200 Winthrop St S.Asbestos Report -Techtron.10-6-21, 18. 200 Winthrop St S.Nova Phase 1 Environmental Site Assessment.12-12-17, 19. 200 Winthrop St S.DSI Staff Report.8-10-23, 20. 200 Winthrop St S.Picture Packet 8-10-2023, 21. 200 Winthrop St S.Myers Rpt re Haven lead & asbestos docs.8-28-23, 22. 200 Winthrop St S.MEC Ltr re HUD Lead-Based Paint Insp & Risk Assmt Rpt 4-26-05, 23. 200 Winthrop St S.DSI Response to HJC 8-9-23 Ltr.10-19-23, 24. 200 Winthrop St S.DSI Response to LH 8-10-23 Testimony.10-19-23, 25. 200 Winthrop St S.Techtron Asbestos Materials Ident.10-25-23, 26. 200 Winthrop St S.DSI Response re Haven Garage Flooding ao 10-23-23, 27. 200 Winthrop St S.Myers Rpt on 10-25-23 Techtron Rpt.11-29-23, 28. 200 Winthrop St S.HJC 2nd Suppl Appeal Ltr.12-14-23, 29. 200 Winthrop St S.Garage Flooding Video.8-11-23, 30. 200 Winthrop St S.Garage Flooding Video #1.12-4-23, 31. 200 Winthrop St S.Garage Flooding Video #2.12-4-23, 32. 200 Winthrop St S.HJC Doc of Marquette-DSI Comm Chart-Timelines, 33. 200 Winthrop St S.Sec 8 Insp Rpts-Redacted.Jan 2021-Jun 2023, 34. 200 Winthrop St S.HJC 3rd Suppl Appeal Ltr.4-16-24, 35. 200 Winthrop St S.Ex A.Memo Supporting Motion for Prelim Inj 23-CV-1740.4-8-24, 36. 200 Winthrop St S.Ex B.Declaration of Greg Myers 23-CV-1740.4-2-24, 37. 200 Winthrop St S.Ex C-Nova Rpt re Asb Mtrls Oper & Mnt Prog.5-13-21, 38. 200 Winthrop St S.Ex D-Motion for Summary Judgment. 62-HG-CV-23-3931.2-23-24, 39. 200 Winthrop St S.email chain 4-18-24, 40. 200 Winthrop St S.Chain email & Ltr to SP Council.6-10-24, 41. 200 Winthrop St S. 2023 & 2024 Complaint Log.7-3-24, 42. 200 Winthrop St S.Construction Bldg Permit Log, 43. 200 Winthrop St S.Wood Email & Move-Out Notice 7-10-24, 44. 200 Winthrop St S.Haven -- Objection to LHO Recomendation 8.9.24.pdf, 45. 200 Winthrop St S.Housing Choice Vouchers at Haven 8-14-24.pdf, 46. 200 Winthrop St S.Objection Overview PPT_2024-08-14 City Council Hearing.pdf, 47. 200 Winthrop St S.Housing Choice Vouchers at Haven.2-1-24.pdf, 48. 200 Winthrop St S.Objection Overview PPT_RLH RSA 24-4 8-14-24.pdf
Related files: RLH FCO 17-230, RLH RSA 23-13

Title

Appeal of Sumeya Mohamed to a Rent Stabilization Determination at 200 WINTHROP STREET SOUTH, APT. 313.  (Amended to grant the appeal)

 

Purpose of Appeal

Ms. Mohamed is primarily appealing on alleged violations by Marquette of the implied warranty of habitability, codified in Minnesota Statutes Section 504B.161. Marquette’s violations of Minn. Stat. 504B.161 prohibit the City from granting Marquette’s rent-increase application. St. Paul, Minn., Legislative Code § 193A.06(c). Ms. Mohamed also argues that Marquette has decreased housing services provided at Haven, unreasonably increased its operating expenses, and that capital improvements have been improperly included in the total rent increase.

 

Date of Determination

May 24, 2023

 

Body

AMENDED 8/14/24

 

WHEREAS, in the matter of Appeal of Sumeya Mohamed to a Rent Stabilization Determination at 200 WINTHROP STREET SOUTH, APT. 313, the Legislative Hearing Officer has reviewed the appeal and considered the testimony of City staff and the appellant;

 

WHEREAS, the Legislative Hearing Officer recommends that the City Council dismiss the appeal, as the appellant no longer has legal standing; Now, Therefore, Be It

 

RESOLVED, that the Saint Paul City Council hereby grant the appeal accepts and adopts the Legislative Hearing Officer's recommendation in this matter.

 

 

Date NameDistrictOpinionCommentAction
No records to display.