Saint Paul logo
File #: APC 24-1    Version: 1
Type: Appeal-Planning Comm Status: Archived
In control: City Council
Final action: 4/10/2024
Title: Considering the appeal of Snelling-Midway Redevelopment, LLC to the Planning Commission decisions for a proposed development on property at 1566 University Avenue West.
Sponsors: Anika Bowie
Ward: Appeal
Code sections: Sec. 61.702. - Appeals to city council.
Attachments: 1. Appeal Application and Supporting Materials, 2. Transformer Locations, 3. Planning Commission Resolution, 4. Planning Commission Action Minutes 3-15-24, 5. Planning Commission Minutes, 6. Zoning Committee Minutes, 7. Staff Report, 8. Variances application and supporting materials, 9. Comment Union Park Letter, 10. Comment Hamline Midway Coalition email, 11. Summary of Zoning Committee and Planning Commission Action, 12. Notice of Appeal and Extension of 60 Day Deadline for Action, 13. Greater MSP Partnership letter, 14. Midway Chamber Statement on United Village 4.4.pdf, 15. St Paul Chamber public comment, 16. St Paul Building Trades public comment, 17. United Village Letter 2 03_18_24 Hotel Driveway Appeal.docx, 18. City Council Presentation for Appeal
Related files: RES 23-1442

Title

Considering the appeal of Snelling-Midway Redevelopment, LLC to the Planning Commission decisions for a proposed development on property at 1566 University Avenue West.

Body

Zoning File: #24-022-766 (Appeal of Zoning File #24-013-570)

File Name: 1566 University Avenue West - Snelling-Midway Redevelopment, LLC Appeal

Appellant: Snelling-Midway Redevelopment, LLC

Applicant: Snelling-Midway Redevelopment, LLC

Address: 1566 University Avenue West - temporary address

Purpose: Appeal of the following Planning Commission decisions: 1) to deny variance #3, the purpose of which is to permit an entrance drive to occupy more than 60 feet of total lot frontage (60 feet maximum permitted, 322 feet requested, for a variance of 262 feet) (variance of Zoning Code Section 66.342(a)(2)); 2) to attach condition #5 to approval of variance #5, requiring additional openings be added to the west façade of the hotel building on floors 3 through 7 (variance of Zoning Code Sec. 63.110(b)); and 3) to attach condition #6 to the approval of variance #6 requiring a connection between the ground level retail space in the parking garage and the open green space to the west be provided to activate the open green space (variance of City Council Resolution RES 23-1442).  Zoning Committee public hearing held on March 7, 2024 and Planning Commission decision made on March 15, 2024. 

Staff Recommendation: Approval with conditions

District Council Recommendations:

Union Park District Council did not take a position on the entrance drive variance (variance #3), noting that more information was needed about traffic management on event days at the stadium.  They supported the variance for door and window openings on the west façade (variance #5) and opposed the variance for ground level door and window openings on the west façade (variance #6).

Hamline-Midway Coalition opposed the entrance drive variance (variance #3) and opposed the variance for ground level door and window openings on the west façade (variance #6).  They did not take a position on the variance for door and window openings on the west façade (variance #5). 

Zoning Committee Recommendation: Approval of entrance drive variance, with conditions (variance #3); approval of variance for door and window openings on the west façade, with conditions (variance #5); and approval of the variance for ground level door and window openings on the west façade, with conditions (variance #6).

Support: 0 people spoke; 0 letters received

Opposition: 0 people spoke, 0 letters received

Planning Commission Decision: Denial of driveway variance (variance #3); approval, with conditions, of the variance for door and window openings on the west façade (variance #5); and approval, with conditions, of the variance for ground level door and window openings on the west façade (variance #6).

Staff assigned: Kady Dadlez, 651-266-6619

Attachments:

Appeal Application and Supporting Materials

Planning Commission Resolution 24-3

Planning Commission Action Minutes

DRAFT Planning Commission Minutes

Zoning Committee Minutes

Staff Report

Variance Applications and Supporting Materials

Applicant Presentation at Zoning Committee

Comment from Union Park

Comment from Hamline-Midway Coalition

Summary of Zoning Committee and Planning Commission Actions

Notice of Appeal and Extension of 60-Day Deadline for Action

 

Date NameDistrictOpinionCommentAction
No records to display.